Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alec L.'s avatar

Very thought provoking... This brought a couple things to the surface of my mind from somewhere deep:

FIRST- Last night in a hotel I happened to flick the TV on and HBO came up. The scene that proceeded feels very aligned with this idea... Check it out @stan and let me know if this accurately captures your ideas presented here, from your perspective:

https://youtu.be/H7cZAe3F3rQ?si=wmIFuTfuwbKgVLnD

SECOND - Your idea of 'The Great Manipulation' resonates deeply with me, though I have a slightly different perspective to it. I believe it's more coy and sneaky, and is cloaked in the form of "Individualism" (though this word is never used overtly). Look no further than modern Burger King commercials, telling viewers to "have it your way...YOU RULE!". But that's innocent advertising right? I'm beginning to think otherwise and I think your article speaks to this.

We're taught that we deserve "success" if we work hard and do the right thing, that everyone can be whatever they want to be when they grow up, to unapologetically be our unique selves. While I believe freedom of ideas and expression is a good thing, I also feel it can also be a breeding ground for the SEPARATION and DEPRESSION you mention. Individualism can also turn into resentment when the world ultimately takes a path that doesn't align with our idealistic worldviews.

I feel this is where Individualism can bite back if we're not aware of its dark side! For example, when a person feels they deserved that promotion more than the colleague who "unfairly" received the recognition and pay raise... The deceitful dark side of individualism starts to spawn, like mold behind a wall, unbeknownst to those living amongst it. Then, the next time we scroll on social media, our lens changes towards comparison (as you aptly mention) to subconsciously prove one of two things to ourselves:

1) "I look/think just like that "successful" person! See, I DID deserve that promotion more than so-and-so.."

> This is the ego's attempt to mend a wound, which strengthens its grip on us and hardens our separate self-identity.

2) "I don't look/think like that "successful" person at all... Maybe my boss was right to not promote me! I don't deserve good things."

> This is an example of how the depression you mention can manifest, beating us into submission and pulling us further away from community.

These are just two examples of how the seeming innocence of Individualism on a BK commercial can eventually fight back, leading to much larger problems, like you mention. Wars over scarce resources, egotistical spats, a wedge between us and loved ones, anxiety and depression epidemics, to name a few.

Fortunately, and unfortunately, these ideas have comes from my own journey with individualism, idealism, comparison, and depressive thoughts. Thankfully I'm becoming more aware of the root causes and learning to overcome them! The journey never ends though.

Please share your thoughts.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts